In the heart of Wisconsin’s Northwoods, where towering pines meet sparkling waters, there’s a timeless tradition that runs as deep as our roots: the Old Fashioned. More than just a drink, it’s a taste of Wisconsin heritage, a warm welcome, and a perfect companion to any Oconto County adventure. We asked our residents and visitors to share their favorite spots for this iconic cocktail, and these five establishments truly stood out. Get ready to discover the ‘Spirit of the Northwoods’ in every sip, presented here in alphabetical order.
Boarding House Supper Club, Suring
At Boarding House, every Old Fashioned is crafted with genuine care and precision, truly from scratch. Their dedicated bartenders meticulously muddle fresh honey, bitters, and your chosen alcohol, then add soda, ice, and finish it all with a perfect garnish and, of course, a smile. It’s this commitment to the classic, hands-on method that ensures every drink is a pure, delightful experience.
Visit Boarding House Supper Club Facebook
Braise North, Lakewood
Step into Braise North for a uniquely unforgettable twist on tradition with their famous ‘Crazy Dave’z Old Fashioned.’ This standout cocktail is a testament to owner Dave Swanson’s legendary energy. It features a mysterious elixir of Bourbon, Angostura bitters, and a distinct blend of 20 hand-grated spices – a secret recipe that’s sure to bring a smile to your face during your weekend escape in Lakewood.
Irish Greens, Oconto
At Irish Greens, their Old Fashioneds proudly uphold Wisconsin’s cherished tradition. Every drink begins the same way: a sugar cube, cherry, fresh orange slice, and a few splashes of bitters, all carefully muddled by their amazing bartenders. While honoring the classic, Irish Greens also loves to experiment with different flavored whiskeys and brandies; their house favorite, the Blackberry Old Fashioned, is a must-try. Plus, enjoy $1 off Old Fashioneds during Happy Hour every day from 3:30 PM to 5:30 PM.
The OC, Oconto
A local favorite renowned for its exceptional and consistent take on this Wisconsin classic. Every Old Fashioned is expertly muddled with fresh ingredients, including beloved Amarena cherries, ensuring a perfect sip every time. Customers rave about their delicious brandy Old Fashioneds and the incredibly friendly, welcoming atmosphere, where bartenders make you feel like old friends, remember your name, and even encourage you to write on the bar (it’s all dry erase!) and stay a while. With good music and a commitment to generously giving back to the community, The OC is truly a welcome breath of fresh air, offering a muddled Old Fashioned that’s genuinely hard to beat.
Weatherwood Supper Club, Mountain
Experience an Old Fashioned that’s truly a ‘rite of passage’ at Weatherwood. Their outstanding bartenders are known for generously pouring and perfectly mixing your choice of whiskey, brandy, or bourbon with bitters, often garnished with a cherry for good measure. The result is a smooth, sweet, and spicy sipper that’s more than just a drink – it’s an experience to be savored. Weatherwood is open Thursday-Sunday at 4:30 PM, with a Double Bubble happy hour from 4:30 PM to 5:30 PM.
Visit Weatherwood Supper Club Facebook
From classic preparations to unique twists, these Oconto County establishments are pouring out the best of Wisconsin’s beloved Old Fashioned tradition. Each one offers not just a drink, but a moment to savor the ‘Spirit of the Northwoods.’ So, next time you’re in our neck of the woods, be sure to visit and raise a glass to unforgettable times and fantastic flavors!
